消委會氣墊粉底|6款驗出致癌物 或致腎病及骨骼脆弱 12款安全滿分品牌一覽
消委會氣墊粉底目錄
消委會氣墊粉底|6款檢出致癌物
消委會該次檢測的30款氣墊粉底,售價範圍由$45至$700不等,測試結果顯示,14款產品含有微量鉛,鉛的濃度介乎0.32ppm至0.91ppm,雖然低於德國規限,但由於鉛有毒性,除了可經由呼吸或飲食攝入,並在體內積聚而造成鉛中毒外,甚至可經由母體傳至胎兒,影響胎兒智力、精神和情緒發展,所以懷孕婦女應慎選化妝品和護膚品。
除了鉛,6款產品還檢出癌物質鎘,鎘含量介乎0.29ppm至0.51ppm,其中3款超出德國規限(0.1ppm),當中「Dior Diorsnow Perfect Light Perfect Glow Cushion」檢出的鎘含量最高,達0.51ppm,超標近4倍。消委會指出,鎘是自然存在於地殼和天然礦物質的金屬元素,同時是致癌物質;雖然鎘透過皮膚吸收的機會較低,但塗抺於嘴唇附近的化妝品就有可能經口腔攝入,或會令鎘積聚於腎臟,導致出現腎臟疾病及令骨骼脆弱。
牌子 | 產品名稱 | 鉛含量(ppm) |
Miniso | Shiyokubutsu From Natural Plants Moisture Cushion Makeup Base | 0.32 |
M.A.C. | Studio Perfect Hydrating cushion Compact N18 SPF 50 PA++ | 0.33 |
Estee Lauder | Double Wear Cushion BB All Day Wear Liquid Compact 1W1 BONE SPF 50 PA+++ | 0.35 |
Color Combos | Bounce Me Up! Mini Cushion Foundation O2 Rosy Pink SPF35 | 0.37 |
Kose Sekkisei | Watery Liquid Cushion 405 SPF30 | 0.37 |
Tom Ford | SOLEIL GLOW TONE UP FOUNDATION HYDRATING CUSHION COMPACT 2.0 BUFF SPF 40 PA+++ | 0.43 |
Dior | Diorsnow Perfect Light Perfect Glow Cushion SPF 50 PA+++ 010 | 0.48 |
Laneige | BB Cushion Whitening No. 21 Beige SPF 50+ PA+++ | 0.49 |
Clarins | Everlasting Cushion Long-Wearing & Hydrating Foundation 105.5 flesh SPF 50 PA+++ | 0.54 |
Lancome | Teint Idole Ultra Wear Cushion High Coverage-All Day Wear PO-02 SPF 23 PA++ | 0.54 |
Sulwhasoo | Perfecting Cushion EX No. 21 Natural (Pink)緻美無瑕氣墊粉底液 自然色(粉色) SPF 50+ PA+++ | 0.61 |
Shiseido | SYNCHRO Skin Glow Cushion Compact Neutral 2 SPF23 | 0.68 |
Nars | Aqua Glow Cushion Foundation Alaska 6803 SPF 23/ PA+++ | 0.71 |
Make Up For Ever | UV Bright Cushion Y225 SPF 35 PA+++ | 0.91 |
消委會氣墊粉底|4款驗出防腐劑 或增乳癌風險
測試還發現,有4款產品檢出防腐劑「對羥基苯甲酸酯」,含量從0.075%至0.14%不等,雖然檢出量符合歐洲的相關要求,但對羥基苯甲酸酯類化合物類似雌激素,有機會干擾人體正常的荷爾蒙分泌,過往曾被指可能與增加患乳癌的風險有關連。
回到目錄
消委會氣墊粉底|12款滿分氣墊粉底推薦
測試中,有12款樣本獲得消委會5分滿分,其中有3分之1的售價低於$300,最便宜的僅售$128,反映價格與產品質素沒有必然關係。
滿分氣墊粉底丨1. Missha Magic Cushion Cover Lasting BB Cushion No. 23 SPF 50+ PA+++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2fe27/2fe27d177a9996f8372060dea1069b8435e6bc3d" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Missha Magic Cushion Cover Lasting BB Cushion No. 23 SPF 50+ PA+++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Missha Magic Cushion Cover Lasting BB Cushion No. 23 SPF 50+ PA+++
售價:$128
滿分氣墊粉底丨2. Tony Moly DOUBLE ESSENCE CUSHION SPF 30 PA+++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/11eb6/11eb69c5864593179db9e6e12ede7bfed7d35ec5" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Tony Moly DOUBLE ESSENCE CUSHION SPF 30 PA+++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Tony Moly DOUBLE ESSENCE CUSHION SPF 30 PA+++
售價:$188
滿分氣墊粉底丨3. Belif Moisture bomb cushion natural beige bullet SPF 42 PA+++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cad6c/cad6c53c29372d5d481523e8b2639a0d45c96867" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 elif Moisture bomb cushion natural beige bullet SPF 42 PA+++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Belif Moisture bomb cushion natural beige bullet SPF 42 PA+++
售價:$280
滿分氣墊粉底丨4. CLIO Nudism Water Grip Cushion SPF 50 PA+++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e3e07/e3e070a4c513f94219a1367928922fe0c9bca508" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 CLIO Nudism Water Grip Cushion SPF 50 PA+++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
CLIO Nudism Water Grip Cushion SPF 50 PA+++
售價:$299
滿分氣墊粉底丨5. Shu uemura unlimited breathable lasting cushion foundation 564 medium light sand SPF 36 PA+++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6388d/6388dd4f82a87598bd77a2d92e6893609545e09f" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Shu uemura unlimited breathable lasting cushion foundation 564 medium light sand SPF 36 PA+++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Shu uemura unlimited breathable lasting cushion foundation 564 medium light sand SPF 36 PA+++
售價:$400
滿分氣墊粉底丨6. The History of Whoo Luxury Golden Cushion Glow 23 SPF 50+ PA+++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3ca14/3ca1425b96aeceefd5d1f705db3977c3b4099ddd" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 The History of Whoo Luxury Golden Cushion Glow 23 SPF 50+ PA+++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
The History of Whoo Luxury Golden Cushion Glow 23 SPF 50+ PA+++
售價:$400
滿分氣墊粉底丨7. Chanel Les Beiges Healthy Glow Gel Touch Foundation SPF 25/PA++ No. 20
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2b275/2b275ff1fa4f321c8864b179367c56ec6e4ff668" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Chanel Les Beiges Healthy Glow Gel Touch Foundation SPF 25/PA++ No. 20(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Chanel Les Beiges Healthy Glow Gel Touch Foundation SPF 25/PA++ No. 20
售價:$480
滿分氣墊粉底丨8. YSL Le Cushion Encre De Peau Fusion Ink Cushion Foundation 30 SPF 23 PA++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c0ed5/c0ed57ecf67559fac58f9c7376b45aa08c33438d" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 YSL Le Cushion Encre De Peau Fusion Ink Cushion Foundation 30 SPF 23 PA++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
YSL Le Cushion Encre De Peau Fusion Ink Cushion Foundation 30 SPF 23 PA++
售價:$480
滿分氣墊粉底丨9. Fancl 氣墊粉底無瑕水潤 BB Cover Cushion 12 SPF 50+ PA++++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/84540/845405228465376ec5ccb8e071fb02cd39d781d5" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Fancl 氣墊粉底無瑕水潤 BB Cover Cushion 12 SPF 50+ PA++++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Fancl 氣墊粉底無瑕水潤 BB Cover Cushion 12 SPF 50+ PA++++
售價:$498
滿分氣墊粉底丨10. Guerlain Parure Gold Cushion Gold Radiance Foundation 01N Pale Beige SPF 25 PA++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/30916/3091666dd9e99e572b29cf32c1422955277b3a29" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Guerlain Parure Gold Cushion Gold Radiance Foundation 01N Pale Beige SPF 25 PA++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Guerlain Parure Gold Cushion Gold Radiance Foundation 01N Pale Beige SPF 25 PA++
售價:$530
滿分氣墊粉底丨11. Giorgio Armani my Armani to go essence-in-foundation cushion 3 SPF 23
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ef16f/ef16f619120c0ae721029ba5acc6ecdb92360147" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Giorgio Armani my Armani to go essence-in-foundation cushion 3 SPF 23(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Giorgio Armani my Armani to go essence-in-foundation cushion 3 SPF 23
售價:$590
滿分氣墊粉底丨12. Cle de Peau Teint Cushion Eclat Radiant Cushion Foundation O20 SPF 25 PA+++
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66cff/66cff4c750903c5cc7c754fcd328db9d840d81cd" alt="消委會氣墊粉底 Cle de Peau Teint Cushion Eclat Radiant Cushion Foundation O20 SPF 25 PA+++(圖片來源:消委會圖片)"
Cle de Peau Teint Cushion Eclat Radiant Cushion Foundation O20 SPF 25 PA+++
售價:$700
*資料源自消委會第525期《選擇》月刊,產品售價及品質或有變更
延伸閱讀:
消委會易潔鑊|消委會測試25款易潔鑊 7款高分抵用最平$70
消委會洗頭水|44款洗頭水含致敏源 16款通過檢測安全名單 最平$70
氣墊粉底含有鉛和鎘是否會危害健康?
根據消委會的測試,鉛和鎘的含量有可能對健康造成風險,尤其是長期使用含有這些成分的產品。鉛可能對孕婦的胎兒智力和情緒發展造成影響,而鎘則可能積聚在腎臟,對骨骼健康造成損害。
防腐劑「對羥基苯甲酸酯」是什麼?
這是一種常見的防腐劑,雖然符合歐洲標準,但它具有類似雌激素的作用,可能干擾荷爾蒙分泌,過量使用有可能增加乳癌風險。
有無對孕婦使用氣墊粉底的建議?
孕婦在選擇化妝品時應格外謹慎,避免使用含有鉛等有害物質的產品。選擇無害的氣墊粉底,能夠有效降低健康風險。